Botley West: what a refused solar farm says about farmland and soil
A refusal letter is the plainest statement of what the government expects from a solar farm on good land. This one is unusually specific about farmland.
On 10 November 2026 the government refused consent for the Botley West solar farm in Oxfordshire. At up to 840MW it would have covered land in West Oxfordshire, Cherwell and the Vale of White Horse. Much of that land belongs to the Blenheim Estate, which the decision letter calls “the majority landowner working with the Applicant”.
In October we used Botley West to show how far a developer’s timetable can run ahead of the consent system, in Solar on farmland: two routes to consent. The decision letter adds something rarer. It is a detailed account, from the decision-maker, of how the best farmland was weighed and what the developer was asked to promise about the soil. This note sets out those parts of it.
The decision in brief
The four inspectors who examined the application recommended refusal, and Baroness Curran, a minister at the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, agreed. The letter names five main issues: harm to the Green Belt, harm to heritage assets including the Blenheim Palace World Heritage Site, harm to the landscape, a risk to aviation safety at London Oxford Airport, and the developer’s approach to the best farmland (paragraph 3.8).
The need for solar was not in doubt. The letter gives it substantial positive weight. Its finding was that the developer had not shown it had avoided and reduced harm as far as it could. National policy gives large solar farms a strong presumption in favour of consent, but only once that has been shown. At Botley West the presumption never applied (paragraph 7.11).
How much of the land was the best land
Farmland in England is graded from 1 to 5 under the Agricultural Land Classification. Grades 1, 2 and 3a are called best and most versatile. National policy asks developers to minimise their use of it and to prefer poorer land where they can (EN-1, paragraph 5.11.12).
At Botley West the best and most versatile land made up 42% of the area for panels, 314 hectares, most of it grade 2 or 3a. Of that, 5.5 hectares would have been lost permanently under the hardstanding of a new National Grid substation (paragraph 4.316).
The developer’s position was that land under panels is a temporary loss, because it can return to farming when the panels are removed. It said sheep would graze around the panels throughout. It also pointed out that national policy does not prohibit solar on the best land, and expects some to be used at this scale (paragraph 4.316).
How the site was chosen
The Secretary of State asked the developer to explain why it had sited the scheme on the best land and what alternatives it had considered (paragraph 4.318). It answered with three points (paragraph 4.320):
- A new map of land quality for England, introduced in March 2026, predicts that 50.48% of farmland is best and most versatile, so any major development is bound to include some.
- Its site held a lower share than the national average, and lower than is typical in Oxfordshire.
- Its panels sit mainly in pockets of fields that would be too small to farm commercially if they were left out.
The same response also said that “the presence or absence of BMV was unlikely to be a determinative factor in site selection providing they could comply with policy requirements” (paragraph 4.320).
The letter was not persuaded. It accepts that a scheme of this size can be expected to use some of the best land, but calls the explanation for the choice of site “unsatisfactory” (paragraph 4.326). It found that the developer had not set out how the best land was avoided. Later reductions in the area affected were made for other reasons, to reduce harm to views and heritage. It concludes that the developer “failed to seek to minimise the impacts” on that land (paragraphs 4.324 and 4.327).
What the soil surveys showed
During the examination the Estate said that much of its land, although graded best and most versatile, was of poor quality and did not support farming. Farmers gave similar accounts. Objectors, including the Campaign to Protect Rural England, asked for evidence (paragraph 4.322).
Soil survey results were eventually submitted by a third party, who had obtained them from Blenheim Palace. They suggested good fertility and good nutrient availability. The inspectors concluded that the land is of good agricultural quality and would be taken out of production for an extended period. The developer did not address the results during the examination. When the Secretary of State asked, it said they did not change its assessment, because the areas sampled were already marked as best and most versatile (paragraphs 4.322 and 4.323).
A grade on a map and the way a field farms can differ, in either direction. At Botley West the claim that graded land farmed poorly carried little weight without evidence, and the evidence that did arrive pointed the other way.
The promise on soil
The inspectors noted that the developer had committed only to reinstating disturbed soils when the scheme was removed, not to restoring them to their starting grade (paragraph 4.317).
The Secretary of State asked for more. The request was for an updated soil management plan that would secure the restoration of the best land “to at least their pre-construction ALC grade upon decommissioning” (paragraph 4.318). The developer sent a revised plan covering how soil would be handled, stored and monitored. The letter found that it made “no specific commitment” to restoring soil to at least its original grade, and that it did not answer the request (paragraph 4.319).
If you are offered a solar option
None of this means solar on good land cannot be consented. Two weeks before Botley West was refused, the same minister granted the 800MW Great North Road solar farm in Nottinghamshire. National policy says each application is considered case by case (EN-1, paragraph 4.2.14). What the letter does show is the questions a decision-maker will ask about farmland, and those are worth asking first.
How has the grade of your land been established? A predictive map is not a field survey. If part of your land is graded best and most versatile, find out whether the developer has surveyed it, and what the survey found.
Will the soil come back to its original grade? Ask whether the developer will commit to returning the soil to at least its pre-construction grade at the end, both in the lease and in what it puts forward for consent. Ask who pays for that. At Botley West the Secretary of State asked for that commitment, and its absence counted against the scheme.
Why your fields? A developer has to justify using the best land. At Botley West the justification that counted was about how the best land had been avoided, not how much of it there is nationally. Ask how your land compares with the alternatives the developer looked at.
What happens if consent is refused? Botley West took just under 2 years from application to refusal. What a refusal means for your option, and for any payments under it, depends on its terms. Take the heads of terms to a solicitor before you sign.
The developer has until 22 December 2026 to bring a claim for judicial review. It could also apply again. A new application would be decided under the national energy policy that took effect in January 2026. It would also have to meet the 10% biodiversity gain objective that has applied to such applications since 2 November.
If you have been approached about solar, or about anything else on your land, our free Land Potential Check gives a first read of the constraints on a piece of land, drawn from national planning data. It is an indication, never a valuation.
Source: Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, Botley West Solar Farm decision letter, 10 November 2026, paragraphs 3.8, 4.316 to 4.327, 7.11 and Annex A; Overarching National Policy Statement for Energy (EN-1), January 2024, paragraphs 4.2.14 and 5.11.12; Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, Great North Road Solar and Biodiversity Park decision, 27 October 2026.
This article is general information and reflects our reading of policy at the time of writing. It is not financial, tax, planning or legal advice, it is not a valuation, and it is not a guarantee of planning permission. Policy changes, and every site and situation is different, so please take your own professional advice before acting on anything set out here.